SON, Engineers Differ on Prime Cause of Building Collapse


The Nigerian Society of Engineers says unlike what the Standards Organisation of Nigeria would want Nigerians to believe, low grade cement is never the prime cause of collapsed buildings in Nigeria

|  By Anayo Ezugwu  |  Jun. 2, 2014 @ 01:00 GMT

THE Standards Or¬ganisation of Nigeria, SON, has directed cement manufacturers in the country to immediately commence the production of the high grade 42.5 cement. It reaffirmed its restriction of the use of the 32.5 low grade cement. Speaking during the just- concluded public hearing conducted by the House of Representatives Ad-hoc Com¬mittee on the composition and pigmentation of cement in the country, Joseph Odumodu, director-general, SON, said the restriction placed on the use of low grade cement was to mitigate the problem of build¬ing collapse in the country.

He said the country could not afford to be different on the issue of cement quality, adding that the world’s progressive coun¬tries had since stopped using the low quality 32.5 cement. The SON boss said his or¬ganisation had restricted the use of 32.5 cement low grade and would enforce compli¬ance, saying those who had decided to continue to produce 32.5 cement low grade were do¬ing  so for profiteering.

But the Nigerian Society of Engineers, NSE, has dismissed as misleading, erroneous and fallacious the attribution of cement grade as the prime causative factor for the incessant collapse of buildings in the country. According to the NSE, the misappropriation or inappropriate application of cement in the production of concrete can be a plausible cause of building collapse, but not the grade of the product.

Ademola Olorunfemi, president, NSE, outlined what could  be the general causes of building collapse to include design flaws, ageing, materials’ fatigue, extreme operational and environmental conditions, accidents, terrorist attacks and natural hazards. “A cursory look at the array of causes of building collapse peculiar to Nigeria will reveal that only two of the 15 causes are overtly or covertly related to the usage of construction materials. Now, a visit to the scene of any collapsed building will reveal rubbles of concrete structural elements and not cement of whatever grade. We will like to state unequivocally that it is misleading, erroneous and fallacious to assert that cement grade is a prime causative factor in the incessant collapse of buildings in Nigeria when, in fact, there is no experimental basis for such an assertion,” he said.

Olorunfemi said buildings were usually constructed to serve defined purposes and designed to avoid collapse under service loads, and to withstand some levels of unforeseen loads. He noted that in recent times, a barrage of articles had appeared in the media on issues pertaining to cement grades and their contributions or otherwise to incessant building collapse in the country. “Today in Nigeria, empirically or experimentally, there is no data on the correlation between concrete strength and the strength of the various grades of cement available in the market.”

Speaking on the different grades, the NSE president said there were three strength classes of Portland cement, 32.5, 42.5 and 52.5 based on the minimum 28-day mortar prime strength. “By this, we mean that the minimum comprehensive strength of cement mortar on the 28th day after pouring corresponds to the grade of that cement. “It is noteworthy that the grade of cement corresponds to the minimum comprehensive strength of cement mortar at 28 days and not the strength of concrete at 28 days,” Olorunfemi added.

He said each cement type or grade had a specific role to play, stressing that the choice would depend on the nature of work to be done, method of construction and local environmental conditions, among other things. “Grade 32.5 cement is suitable for general paving and mass concreting, in addition to its use in sundry masonry works such as plastering/rendering, block moulding/setting and other light concrete works. It will meet the structural requirements of most small-scale consumers. Grade 42.5 cement is suitable for residential, commercial and industrial structures, including heavy concrete works such as heavy retaining walls, large piers and abutments, flyovers, and dams/marine constructions, among others. Grade 52.5 cement is used for projects where very high level of strength is needed, e.g. the construction of skyscrapers, bridges and heavy load bearing structures.”

(Visited 10 times, 1 visits today)