AN Argentine court has dismissed an attempt to enforce a fraudulent $9.5 billion Ecuadorian judgment against Chevron Corporation in the country. In a 22-page decision, the National Civil Court No. 61 in Buenos Aires, found the plaintiffs failed to prove that the case had any connection to Argentina, that would justify recognition of the 2011 Ecuadorian judgment by the country’s courts.
The court found that Chevron Corporation is not domiciled and has no assets in Argentina, which seals the fate of the present exequatur as it is inadmissible to recognise a foreign decision in this jurisdiction where the defendant has no point of connection. The court relied on a previous decision from the Argentina Supreme Court which found that Chevron’s indirect subsidiary in Argentina, Chevron Argentina SRL, is a separate entity from Chevron Corporation; not a party to the Ecuadorian lawsuit; and an embargo against its assets in support of the Ecuadorian judgment is manifestly contrary to Argentinean public policy. The opinion awards costs to Chevron as the prevailing party.
- Hewitt Pate, vice president and general counsel, Chevron, said once again, attempts to profit from this fraudulent judgment have been rejected. “We are confident that any jurisdiction that observes the rule of law and examines the facts will similarly find the Ecuadorian judgment to be illegitimate and unenforceable.”
Dismissal of the recognition action in Argentina is the latest setback for the lawyers behind the fraudulent lawsuit. A U.S. federal court ruled in 2014 that the Ecuadorian judgment was unenforceable in the United States. In a 500-page opinion, the court found Steven Donziger, the American lawyer behind the lawsuit, and his associates violated federal racketeering laws to obtain the judgment, committing extortion, money laundering, wire fraud, Foreign Corrupt Practices Act violations, witness tampering and obstruction of justice.
The court’s extensive findings were unanimously upheld on appeal last year and, in June, the U.S. Supreme Court denied Donziger’s petition seeking review of the matter. Attempts to enforce the fraudulent judgment in other jurisdictions have been met with similar resistance.
In October 2017, Reporting Justice Luis Felipe Salomão, of Brazil’s Superior Court of Justice, issued his vote rejecting the attempted recognition of the Ecuadorian judgment against Chevron Corporation in that country. Justice Salomão cited a lack of jurisdiction and extensive evidence of fraud and corruption that would make its recognition a violation of public policy.
In January 2017, a Canadian court rejected an attempt to enforce the Ecuadorian judgment against Chevron’s subsidiary, Chevron Canada Limited. The court found that Chevron Canada is a separate entity from Chevron Corporation, not a party to the Ecuadorian lawsuit and not a debtor to the judgment.
In 2015, the Supreme Court of Gibraltar issued a judgment against Amazonia Recovery Ltd., a company set up by Donziger and his associates to receive and distribute funds from the fraudulent Ecuadorian judgment, awarding Chevron$28 million in damages and issuing a permanent injunction against Amazonia that prevents that company from supporting the case against Chevron in any way.
Chevron has never operated in Ecuador. Texaco Petroleum, TexPet, which became a subsidiary of Chevron in 2001, was a minority partner in an oil-production consortium in Ecuador along with the state-owned oil company, Petroecuador, from 1964 to 1992. After TexPet turned its remaining share of the oil operations over to Petroecuador in 1992, pursuant to an agreement with Ecuador, TexPet agreed to conduct a remediation of selected production sites while Petroecuador remained responsible to perform any remaining cleanup.
The government of Ecuador oversaw and certified the successful completion of TexPet’s remediation and fully released TexPet from further environmental liability. Petroecuador, however, failed to conduct the cleanup it promised and has continued to operate and expand oil operations in the former concession over the past 20 years.
Chevron Corporation is one of the world’s leading integrated energy companies. Through its subsidiaries that conduct business worldwide, the company is involved in virtually every facet of the energy industry. Chevron explores for, produces and transports crude oil and natural gas; refines, markets and distributes transportation fuels and lubricants; manufactures and sells petrochemicals and additives; generates power; and develops and deploys technologies that enhance business value in every aspect of the company’s operations.
– Nov 3, 2017 @ 14:15 GMT |